Mayor Nestor Archival has defended the arrest of a 68-year-old harmonica player in Colon Street, saying the city’s anti-mendicancy ordinance applies even when individuals use containers for voluntary donations in public spaces.
The case involves Ireneo Vidal, who was apprehended on May 7 by the Cebu City Anti-Mendicancy Office under an ordinance prohibiting solicitation in public places. The incident has drawn public criticism online and renewed debate on how the policy is enforced, particularly involving elderly and impoverished individuals.
Vidal, however, said he was not begging but performing music to raise money for food for his three-year-old grandchild. His release later led to an emotional reunion with his family that circulated widely on social media.
Archival maintained that the arrest was consistent with the city’s enforcement of the ordinance.
“This is debatable. If wala siya nagbutang so wala siya nangayo in any way, but nagbutang man gud siya,” Archival said during a press conference.
“Lisod kaayo hunahunaon kay muingon ka gitagaan ra ka, wala ka nangayo, pero nagbutang ka og butanganan og sinsilyo — you’re asking, ‘Please give me,’” he added.
The mayor also urged the public and organizations to avoid directly giving money or food to street mendicants, saying such actions may encourage more individuals to stay or travel to the city.
“Usa sa naka-encourage ang mga tawo nga muanhi sa atong syudad tungod sa mga tawo nga kusog kaayo manghatag,” Archival said.
He added that regular feeding activities in some areas also contribute to the presence of mendicants in public spaces.
“Murag gi-encourage nato ang mga tawo nga muanhi para mahatagan,” he said.
Archival instead encouraged the public to coordinate with the Department of Social Welfare and Services (DSWS), which he said has programs and facilities for indigent individuals.
“Mao na naa tay anti-mendicancy law nga if possible ayaw ninyo tage,” he said.
He also asked residents to report similar cases through official city channels so authorities could respond.
The arrest has triggered discussions on social media about poverty, dignity, and the treatment of elderly individuals relying on informal income sources.
Vidal’s supporters said he was simply playing music in public while trying to support his grandchild, while also alleging possible mistreatment during the arrest—claims that are now under review by city authorities.
Councilor Jun Alcover Jr., who assisted in securing Vidal’s release, earlier said he plans to push for a council inquiry into the incident and the alleged abuse.
The Cebu City Anti-Mendicancy Office has maintained that Vidal had previously been apprehended multiple times and referred to social welfare programs.
The case has also renewed attention on Cebu City Ordinance No. 1631, which penalizes mendicancy in public spaces. (VCL)
Photo courtesy of Chito Aragon
Comments